Comparing Period Underwear: Knix VS Thinx

UPDATED: JANUARY 2024

I LOVE talking about all things period - and I've been pretty open about my own period routine. If you've been keeping up with the blog, you know that I switched to a menstrual cup over 2 years ago and have been loving it. But lately, there's been tons of talk about period underwear. I'm a member of a variety of women's groups and there's always questions popping up asking if period underwear are worth it, which brand to get, etc. 

Because I want to continue minimizing my carbon footprint, be part of the conversation, and help women make a well-informed purchase - I bought a pair of period underwear from Knix and a pair from Thinx

knix underwear review, thinx underwear review

Knix Review

Cost: $39.55 (for 1 pair with tax & shipping)

Construction: Seamless, absorbant gusset

Performance: Great for medium - light days

Knix is a Toronto-based company, that sells bras, underwear and previously loungewear. I have purchased one of their bras in the past, as well as regular underwear which is made from nylon and Lycra and is seamless.

Their leakproof line is designed for periods and some underwear can hold up to 3-5 super tampons-worth of fluid, which is roughly 35-60mL.

I should mention that I don’t use Knix underwear on their own (despite being able to hold quite a bit of fluid), I always use them with my menstrual cup. As of 2024 this is what my routine looks like:

  • Leakproof high rise —> These are my daytime choice, especially while working. I feel like my body has changed since both pregnancies, and the high rise just keeps everything ‘in.’

  • bikini —> These are my at-home/back up

  • dream shorts —> Overnight holy grail. I may never need to use hydrogen peroxide again (IYKYK). If you’re going to get any one of these products - this is the one. Do it for your bedsheets.

Their leakproof underwear is designed very similarly to their regular line - both are seamless, the body is made from nylon and Lycra, the only difference is that the leakproof pair has a lined crotch (also known as a gusset), which is 86% cotton. Since buying my first pair, the gusset has changed and covers a wider area, making me feel more protected during my cycle.

Caring for them is simple, I wash them with like-colours (I usually put them in the Knix undergarment bag) and dry them in the dryer in the same bag.

2 MONTH UPDATE: Still going strong! Like I've said, I've purchased other Knix underwear in the past and it still looks good as new. 

6 MONTH UPDATE: The ironed seam (at the gusset) has come loose, which is incredibly disappointing (I have not noticed this issue with my older Knix underwear). This has left some of the padding exposed. That said, I will continue to use them (especially since they were over $40!). 

2019 UPDATE: I bought another leakproof pair for $9 (!!!) at Knix's first warehouse sale. I also bought a few bras (evolution, 8 in 1), pyjamas (I hope they consider selling these again), and evolution top which I have yet to wear. I really like this company, and I'm so happy that I found a wire-free bra that feels and looks great! 

2020 UPDATE: The PJs have been re-released!

2021 UPDATE: I used the dream shorts during my postpartum period - specifically the few weeks after my cesarean birth. I found the shorts to be quite comfortable, as they didn’t aggravate or rub against my scar. I lined the shorts with a Natracare maternity pad (the shorts acted as my insurance policy). The gusset is a bit bigger compared to the regular underwear and does extend more at the front and back - though not completely all the way.

I recommend buying a pair of these for the postpartum - regardless of the type of birth you’re planning on having. It’s a nice sustainable alternative to underwear like Depends and Frida Mom underwear (which is also great, but are disposable).

2022 UPDATE: The shorts are incredible. Once my period returned, I did notice it was a bit heavier than it usually is. So I’m currently pairing the shorts with a menstrual cup on my heavy days #IYKYK

2023 UPDATE: I’m going through the postpartum period again, and recovering from a vaginal birth. The shorts were a staple and I used them with the Natracare pads (again), as well as the Frida Mom ice pads. Once my period returned (a bit heavier than usual), the shorts remained my #1 for protection at night.

2024 UPDATE: I don’t think I’d give up my leakproof Knix underwear at this point. it’s become an essential period routine. Knix doesn’t sell non-super leakproof anymore, and while I do have a couple of pairs hanging around, they are my back-ups - I’m not reaching for them as often.

Thinx Review

Cost: $43.97 (for 1 pair with discount and shipping)

Construction: Not seamless, fully lined, extra layer from front of the gusset extending to the back

Performance: Great for heavy days and overnight

Thinx is an American-based company that only sells period-proof underwear - although they do have a sister company called Speax designed for women who experience urinary incontinence. Thinx is moisture-wicking, anti-microbial, absorbent and leakproof. My pair is made with breathable PUL fabric, and the inside layer is 95% cotton (which is great for those who suffer from chronic vaginal infections). I purchased the scarlet hiphuggers, that are designed to hold 2 tampons worth of fluid. Like Knix, they have various styles (like boy shorts) that hold different amounts of liquid. 

These are fully lined and feel heavier than Knix. I wore these during my heavier days, including overnight. They felt very snug and secure, adding to that extra sense of overnight security. When I did notice some slight leakage during the day and night, the Thinx absorbed everything and did not stain any clothes or sheets! Taking care of the Thinx was also rather simple. After I finished using them, I rinsed them in water, machine washed in cold water and tossed them in the dryer. They do advise to hang them to dry, but I've stopped doing that. 

2 MONTH UPDATE: The threads of the band have started to get a bit loose and pull at the top. For a product that costs more than $50, this is really disappointing. I don't believe that all pairs have this band, so it may not affect the other pairs. However you may want to make this consideration if purchasing the hiphuggers. 

6 MONTH UPDATE: No other threads have come loose. Aside from that minor issue 4 months ago, everything has remained the same. 

2019 UPDATE: I have 2 pairs of the Thinx now, the last pair I got on sale for about $32.00 Canadian. If you can get them on sale, I would recommend it for heavier days.  

2020 UPDATE: A recent report has come out indicating a discovery of chemicals in the gusset of the underwear: "polyfluoroalkyl substances (PFAS) on the inside layers of the crotch. These are chemicals known to be toxic to humans, even at very low levels, and have been linked to cancer and fertility problems." The original report is linked here - where the author sent in a pair of unwashed Thinx and Lunapads to be tested for chemicals.

Since then, Thinx has published a blog post about their products being body safe and have stated: "The truth is that US regulations aren’t as strict as those in the EU, which is why we comply with both US regulations and the EU’s REACH regulations. For example, while the US has banned 11 chemicals from cosmetics, REACH bans 1,328. By complying with REACH, we’re also supporting REACH pre-market testing requirements — all to protect our customers’ safety and wellbeing."

2023 UPDATE: I don’t wear my Thinx products anymore. I think it was a combination of the above report, my size changed (and I didn’t want to repurchase), and they just weren’t as comfortable as the Knix. On my heavier days, I stick to the Dream Short and it works like a charm!

knix underwear review, thinx underwear review

knix underwear review, thinx underwear review

Final Thoughts

2023 UPDATE: I initially felt like this was a pricey experiment - but 5 years later, I’ve changed my mind. Yes, the upfront cost can be pricey, but it’s about the same as a menstrual cup. And just think of all the clothes or sheets you don’t need to wash in a panic! I use my Knix products all the time - I stocked up on the Dream Short after my second birth! I love supporting a Canadian business, and let’s be honest when Knix has sales, I do take advantage of them!

Out of all the products I have (and I have many after about 5 years), the shorts have honestly been the best investment for me. I pair them with my menstrual cup, and paired them with other products in the postpartum - and always felt secure (IYKYK). Knix often has mid-year sales, so keep an eye out for those if you’re interested in trying a pair!

Previous
Previous

Mood Disorders and Your Period

Next
Next

Iron: the most common nutritional deficiency in women